Straighten Your Tefillin One More Time
A guy at YU spent twenty minutes putting on his tefillin. Years later, working in AI, I finally understood what I was watching.
Memory is a funny thing.
There are important things I forget instantaneously, and then there are moments from ten or fifteen years ago that just stick with me, for no good reason at all. I couldn't tell you about most of my mornings at YU. But I can tell you about this one.
There was a minyan in the basement of a popular campus dormitory ironically known as Morg. One morning at 7:40 Shacharis I ended up sitting next to a guy I would call my acquaintance. He was roughly 5'10", brown hair, frum, really your average YU student. I'd seen him around, had a few classes with him, and had said hi to him several times. Not a close friend, but not a stranger either. That morning, though, I saw him in a new light.
As I threw on my tefillin and opened up my siddur, I couldn't help glancing over at the scene to my left. This acquaintance was putting on his tefillin. Then taking them off. Then putting them on again. He'd wrap the straps and unwrap them, making sure there were seven wraps and that they sat perfectly evenly spaced. Then the shel rosh: a little to the left, a little to the right, a look in his mirror, another adjustment. Then off again, and back to the straps. I'd guess he adjusted it something like 45 times. It took him around twenty minutes. By the time his tefillin were finally set and he could start davening, we were 25 minutes into a 40-minute Shacharis.
I was supposed to be davening. Instead I was mesmerized. I couldn't stop watching.
It looked like some version of religious OCD, and my first thought was: this must be a nuisance for him. Is he plagued by this? He's missing most of the davening. But at the same time, he didn't look annoyed. He didn't look rushed or tormented. He looked focused. There was an intentionality to his motion. I didn't know what to make of it, so I filed it away, and it's been popping back into my head on ocassion ever since.
Recently it came back for a reason. But to explain why, I need to talk about my day-to-day life with my favorite work colleague and topic of conversation, AI.
The thing I actually worry about
AI is my whole day. I work for an AI startup, I build with it, I talk to it constantly. So I think about it a lot, in a lot of different ways.
And one thing I think about on occasion is how AI has the ability to make us dumber. You see it in every op-ed from a teacher discussing how kids can't think critically anymore, because why would they? Type a question into a chat box and you get an answer. Ask for an essay and you get an essay. When all the knowledge is at your fingertips, you never have to learn how to apply it.
Rav Aharon Lopiansky made this point in a piece I read a year or two ago in Mishpacha magazine. As I remember it, he said he wasn't worried about AI destroying the world, and he wasn't worried about it taking all the jobs, like many of the negative AI press typically focuses on. He was instead worried about it crippling our ability to think. Not stripping it away, exactly. Outsourcing it. We have an artificial mind we can throw anything at, and it spits back a response we can regurgitate. So why use brain power thinking about things.
That fear is real. But I do think we have the answer to it staring us right in the face.
The Antidote
Chazal tell us that everything can be found in the Torah, and that Torah is the antidote or potion for life. Rashi famously brings down that Hashem always creates the refuah before the machla, the cure before the disease. Hashem has the master plan. And so for every problem that may arise, the solution already exists.
I've never felt that more strongly than when I was thinking about AI.
Here's the thing about Torah: the point has never been the output. The Gadol Hador isn't whoever has the most encyclopedic knowledge. The gedolim we look up to and celebrate are the 80- and 90-year-old rabbis who have been sitting and toiling for their Torah for seventy plus years. The ikkar of Torah, the most noble part of it, is the ameilus. The toil. Sitting, grinding through it, breaking your teeth on it.
There are no shortcuts to becoming a talmid chacham. Nothing speeds it up. Being gifted and bright is certainly a great start, but you still cannot take a fast pass to the top.
So imagine an AI that knew all of Torah, every sugya, every Rishon, instantly. It would be a great resource, sure. But having it wouldn't move you one inch further in your own learning. If you somehow had AI's grasp of Torah handed to you, it wouldn't change your standing at all. Torah only counts what you poured into it: the effort, the energy, the time.
AI might be stripping our ability to think. Torah demands us to elevate our ability to think.
That's what I mean when I say Torah is the antidote. The whole Torah lifestyle that we Orthodox Jews grow up with already has the anti-AI perspective built in. AI might be stripping our society's ability to critically think. Yet Torah requires us to think. It demands our intentionality and focus and brainpower. The cure was written before the disease.
AI is potentially the greatest tool and invention in human history. I don't think anyone is arguing to revolt against innovation and refuse to use it, in fear of the intellectual malaise. However, when you only drink the poisoned water without simultaneously taking the antidote, you become disillusioned. Only when you have a healthy dose of the antidote in your life, can you be certain to avoid the negative affects of the modern peril.
When you learn that the input is just as, if not more important than the output, everything can click into place.
Back to the Morg
Which brings me back to that fellow in the Morg.
When this reflection about Torah and ameilus was on my mind, he's who I thought of. And I started to wonder whether I'd had it backwards all these years. Maybe tefillin and tefillah aren't linear - either you said all the words with the minyan or you didn't. The output is not the only thing that matters. Maybe his focus and intensity, getting every strap aligned and the shel rosh exactly in place, was the ikkar. Maybe he didn't miss the davening at all. Maybe that was his davening.
Maybe it was OCD. I honestly don't know. But I choose to believe there was something right in what he was doing, compulsion or not. He wasn't losing anything. He was pouring himself into the mitzvah of tefillin until it was done correctly, to his liking. That's ameilus. In a world where the quick fix is at everyone's fingertips, pouring your time into perfecting what matters is exactly what Hashem wants us to be doing.
Because when it comes to yiddishkeit, it's not strictly about the output. It's almost more important to focus on the input. It's to pour your heart into it, your energy, your life. To love the mitzvos and Torah. To be intentional and focused on it.
That's what Hashem wants from us. And no ChatGPT premium subscription can do that for you.
In a world of AI monkeys, be the Torah scholar.
By day, Yoni Schwartz is the Head of Data Science at a rapidly growing healthcare startup- Magicare AI. By night, he's the Producer wearing a number of different hats for everyone's favorite Jewish podcast network, Living Lchaim. In between, he finds a few minutes to jot down his thoughts.